Insurance Pro Shop

November 9, 2026 · By Jeremy Nason

Want to Know the Secret to Closing More Insurance Sales? Stop Looking for Secrets

Stop searching for a magic fix

Why the best agents aren’t the best talkers. They’re the best listeners.

Want to know the secret to closing more insurance sales?

Stop looking for secrets!

I see this all the time. An agent struggles to make sales, so what do they do?

They buy another course. Download another script. Watch another video. Try a new presentation.

Then, when results don’t change right away, they start searching again. Maybe the next course has the answer. Maybe the next script. Maybe the next video.

Sound familiar?

Cartoon agent buried under books, courses, binders, and laptop screens while a lightbulb floats above

The problem may be in the conversation

You may be trying to fix your results without fixing the way you talk with prospects.

A good script can help. A clear presentation can help. But neither one can do the work for you if you don’t understand what matters to the person sitting across from you.

How can you recommend the right solution if you don’t understand the problem?

And how can someone make a decision if they haven’t yet decided there’s a problem worth fixing?

That’s why closing more insurance sales starts before you present a product. It starts with a real conversation about what the prospect wants and what matters to them.

Scripts can help you learn how a conversation works. They can show you what to listen for and how one question can lead to another. But don’t treat them as lines to memorize and repeat. Use them to learn, then build a natural way of talking that lets you listen and adjust.

The best salespeople listen

The best salespeople aren’t necessarily the best talkers. They’re the best thinkers and listeners.

They know what questions to ask. They know when to dig deeper. And most importantly, they know when to keep their mouths shut.

That doesn’t mean you need to ask a long list of questions. It means you need to pay attention to the answers you get. What does the person care about? What are they trying to change? What’s getting in the way?

Give the prospect room to explain. Don’t rush to fill every quiet moment with another feature or benefit.

When you understand what they want, you can talk about options that fit their goals. That’s a better place to begin than starting with a product.

The same idea guides Found Money Management: start with a client’s goals and cash flow. Help them look at where money is going before you suggest a new product.

Try three better questions

Here’s my suggestion.

Instead of learning ten new closing techniques this week, work on asking three better questions. Master those. Then build from there.

I’m not going to list the three questions here, because the right questions depend on the person and the conversation. A question that helps one prospect may not fit the next one.

That’s the skill: knowing what to ask, when to ask it, and when to listen.

Do you want more appointments that stall, or conversations that move forward because the prospect feels heard? Sometimes the biggest improvements come from doing less, but doing it better.

Stop collecting. Start listening.

If you want help with questions, listening, and sales conversations, come work on them with us inside the Insurance Marketing and Sales Resource Center.

Every Thursday, we run a live coaching and training class, where agents bring their real questions, their real cases, and the conversations that stumped them that week. You bring what happened. We work on it together.

That’s where this skill gets built. Not from another course you watch alone, but from practice, feedback, and reps.

Membership is $59.95 per month. Join us this Thursday →

You can also check the upcoming live class dates for Master IUL and Whole Life Sales.

Good Selling Everyone!

Jeremy Nason
Mentor | Coach | Consultant

P.S. If you’re wondering what those three better questions are, that’s exactly the kind of thing we work through live. Every Thursday, agents bring me the conversation that stumped them that week, and we fix it together. Not theory. Your actual appointment. If this article described you, come sit in on a Thursday class and bring that conversation with you. → Join us here