Insurance Pro Shop

November 12, 2026 · By Jeremy Nason

You Don’t Have to Use All the Money (An Annuity Sales Tip That Wins Trust)

Annuity Sales Tip – You Don’t Have to Use All the Money

Linda is 66. She just retired. That’s not her real name, but her story is real.

She gets $3,800 a month from Social Security and a small pension. Her bills and fun money come to $5,800 a month.

That leaves a $2,000 gap every month.

Linda had about $600,000 saved. Her plan was to take money out when she needed it. But when the market dropped, she got scared.

She kept asking, “Am I going to run out?”

We didn’t put all her money in one place. We split it in two.

We used about $335,000 to buy an annuity that pays her roughly $2,000 a month for life. The check shows up every month, good market or bad market.

We left the other $265,000 in her name. She can use it for trips, emergencies, or her grandkids. Some is in savings for emergencies. The rest is invested.

A few months later, Linda called me. She said, “I finally stopped checking my account every morning.”

That’s the kind of call I love.

Retired woman relaxing with a coffee in her cozy living room on a bright morning

My tip: Start with the gap

Don’t start by talking about the product.

Start with the gap.

Ask what comes in and what goes out. Find out how much is missing. Then look at what it might take to fill that gap.

People feel better when they don’t have to hand over everything. They want to know their bills are paid and that they still have money they can use.

This is a natural example of Found Money Management. You start with the client’s cash flow and goals. You find the gap before you talk about a product.

In other words, diagnose before you prescribe.

If you’ve been thinking about insurance prospects ghosting, check whether you’re starting with a product before you understand the client’s needs. When prospects go quiet after a meeting, a clearer look at the client’s money may help you find what matters most to them.

How We Got There

People ask me, “How did you figure out the numbers?”

It wasn’t magic. We sat down, talked through the facts, and did the math.

1. We wrote down what comes in.

At our first meeting, I asked Linda about her Social Security and pension. We added them up.

That came to $3,800 a month.

You can start with simple questions about income and cash flow. The goal is to understand the client’s full picture, not to rush into a product.

2. We wrote down what goes out.

Next, we went through Linda’s bills together. We looked at her mortgage, food, car, insurance, phone, and medicine.

We counted the bills she had to pay. Her must-pay bills came to $3,800 a month. Add her fun money, and she was spending $5,800 a month.

This step matters more than it looks. If you guess at what a client can afford, or skip the bill-by-bill talk, the plan never feels like theirs. Guessing is one more reason prospects go quiet.

3. We found the gap.

We subtracted the $3,800 coming in from the $5,800 going out.

That left $2,000 a month to address.

It wasn’t her whole retirement plan. It was one gap in her monthly income.

4. We asked, “What do you want your money to do?”

This was the big talk.

Linda told me three things:

“I want my bills paid no matter what.”

“I want money I can get to if something happens.”

“If I pass away early, I want something left for my kids.”

Those wishes helped shape the plan. Remember that listening for what a person wants can matter more than adding another product detail.

Two separate groups of coins on a table, showing savings divided into two parts

5. We only used what it took.

I looked at a few insurance companies to see what each one could offer.

We found one, National Life Group, that would pay a little over $2,000 a month for life for about $335,000.

We also picked an option that pays her kids anything left over if she passes away before she gets her money back. That helped address her wish to leave something for them.

A client’s needs and the terms of each contract are different. Review the details and explain the choices before making a recommendation.

6. We kept the rest in her name.

The other $265,000 stayed in her name and was untouched by the annuity.

Some went into savings for emergencies. The rest stayed invested so it could keep growing and help with rising prices down the road.

The point was not to use every dollar. It was to use what the plan called for and leave the rest available for Linda’s other goals.

7. We checked in.

We plan to meet once a year.

We’ll look at her bills, savings, and how she’s feeling. If something changes, we’ll talk about whether the plan needs to change too.

Advisor and retired woman reviewing papers together at a kitchen table during a calm annual check-in

The big lesson

Linda didn’t need a fancy 30-page plan.

She needed someone to sit down with her, do the math, and listen to what mattered to her.

The annuity was just the tool. Listening is what made it work.

That’s worth remembering if prospects going quiet has you focused only on your presentation. Start with the person. Ask what comes in, what goes out, and what they want their money to do. Then talk about possible next steps.

If you want help working through real cases, bring your questions to the live coaching and training class every Thursday inside the Insurance Marketing and Sales Resource Center. Members can bring real cases and conversations that stumped them that week. Membership is $59.95 per month.

Join us this Thursday

You can also learn more in the upcoming Master IUL and Whole Life Sales class.

Good Selling Everyone!

Jeremy Nason


Frequently Asked Questions

What does “you don’t have to use all the money” mean?

It means you first find the client’s monthly income gap. Then you look at what amount may help address it, while considering the client’s other needs and goals.

How do you find a client’s monthly retirement income gap?

Write down the monthly income and the monthly bills. Subtract income from bills to see what amount is missing.

Why split retirement savings into two parts?

One part may be used to help meet a stated income need. The other part can stay in the client’s name for savings, emergencies, trips, or other goals.

What questions should I ask before recommending an annuity?

Ask what money comes in, what goes out, what the client wants their money to do, and what they want to keep available. Understand their wishes before discussing a product.

How often should I review a retirement income plan?

In Linda’s case, we plan to meet once a year. Review the client’s bills, savings, and feelings, and discuss changes if their situation shifts.