Mutual Funds Vs Deferred Annuities!

Success Tip... Mutual Funds Vs Deferred Annuities!

3/1/2023… In recent years, you have not been able to pick up a newspaper, or magazine that doesn’t have an article touting the benefits of investing in mutual funds… Verses deferred annuities. Which one makes more sense for most people? Is selling a deferred annuity a  better option for most families?

The first mutual fund was invented back in the 1930s. But it didn’t really become popular until the great bull market of 1982 to 2000.  Since then, mutual funds have been pushed by many financial advisors as the only way to invest!  Almost everyone has owned mutual funds at some point… If only through their company 401k or personal IRA.  Many people still own mutual funds in spite of the recent stock market declines. And the current scandals surrounding the investment industry.

In the past 50 years, mutual funds have gone from an $18 billion also-ran in the financial services industry… To a $12 trillion titan.  Mutual Funds now enjoy an unchallenged position of leadership, with 90 million US investors.

Most of the growth of mutual funds is attributed to the introduction of 401ks and other qualified plans during the past two decades.  Today, 10% of household financial assets are invested in 401K and Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs). That is up from 6 percent in 1990. And mutual funds manage 47% of those assets.  Households also have invested in mutual funds outside of qualified plans.  Mutual funds manage $4.4 trillion of assets that households hold in those taxable accounts.

Mutual Funds Performance

And, it is no wonder mutual funds became so popular in the 80s and 90s, when the media and investment houses were reporting huge unprecedented returns, in the US stock market.

In the 80s the S&P 500 Index (the benchmark everyone compares to) went from 107.94 to 353.40.  That is an average annual return of 12.59% over those 10 years.

In the 90s, we had one of the best times in history for the U.S. stock market.  The S&P 500 Index went from 353.40 to 1469.25.  That is a staggering total return of 347% in just 10 years or an average annual return of 15.31%.

Now compare that to the lackluster years of the 60s and 70s:

In the 60s the S&P 500 Index went from 59.89 to 92.06.  That is an average annual return of 4.39% over those 10 years.

In the 70s the S&P 500 Index went from 92.06 to 107.94.  That is an average annual return of only 1.60% per year, over those 10 years.

If you had actually received annual returns comparable to those of the S&P 500 Index during those 40 years (1960 through 2000) you would have averaged 8.33% per year.

However, consider that most mutual funds wonít even come close to matching the S&P 500 Index over 30 or 40 years.  Then you subtract the annual fees. This will give you an entirely different view of the validity and benefits of investing in mutual funds vs deferred annuities.

Average Mutual Fund Expenses

Sales charge                                  1.01%
12b-1 fees                                     0.37%
Expense ratio                                 1.35%
Transaction costs*                         1.32%
Total                                             4.05%

*The average turnover of all mutual funds is 110%.  The average transaction fee is estimated at 1.2%.  This is an estimate only as mutual funds do not have to reveal this number and therefore do not.

So, even if you were lucky enough to find a mutual fund that had a total return comparable to that of the S&P 500 Index over the past 40 years, your net return after expenses would only be 4.28%.  (8.33-4.05)  Remember, you will pay those expenses each year, whether your investment makes money or not.

To fully understand the impact of expenses Glorianne Stromberg, a financial services expert was quoted as saying…  “Every 1% you pay in fees or charges will reduce your capital by about 20% over 25 years.  That could mean the difference between being comfortably well off and struggling to make ends meet.”

As an example, at 10% per year, a $10,000 investment compounded over fifty years would yield $1,170,000. The same investment compounded at only 8% would yield just $470,000.  That is a whopping sixty-percent difference amounting to $700,000.

And, we haven’t even considered that from the beginning of 2000 through 2008, the S&P 500 Index has gone down from 1,469.25 to 903.25.  That is a total loss of (-38.53%) or an average annual loss of (-5.90%) over those 8 years.  Overall, the average mutual fund plunged 30% in 2008, and many didn’t fare as well as the S&P 500 index, which fell 38% for its worst year since 1937.

If you add in the last 8 years, the average return for the S&P 500 Index over the past 48 years is only 5.82%.  Now, subtract the average expenses of 4.05% and your net return is only 1.77%.  And, that is only if you were lucky enough to have found a mutual fund that performed as well as the S&P 500 Index over those 48 years.

What is your chance of picking a mutual fund that performed as well as the S&P 500 Index?

Since 1960, the mutual fund industry has grown from 160 funds and $18 billion in assets under management.  Today there are over 8,000 stock mutual funds with combined assets of $12.356 trillion.  During the 1990s, 55% of equity funds failed almost four times the 14% failure rate of the 1960s.

Most people tend to pick mutual funds based on recent performance history.  When do you think a mutual fund company decides to advertise a specific fund?  Is it just after a bad period or a great period?  Of course, they advertise a fund just after it has had a great return… And typically, just as it is about to cool off.  These hot funds historically do very poorly after their best period.  After studying mutual fund performance figures over a 20-year period, I have found that over the subsequent 3, 5, and 10-year periods, a whopping 80% of these funds performed worse than the average similar fund.

Unfortunately, according to the folks at the Motley Fool, only 10 of the ten thousand actively managed mutual funds available today, managed to consistently beat the S&P 500 Index over the past ten years.  Remember, history tells us that very few, if any, of these top-performing mutual funds will manage to beat the S&P 500 Index in the next 10 years.

The recent dismal performance of mutual funds has contributed to the anguish of most retirement investors. They saw a slump in their 401Ks that will probably prolong their working lives.  And, with the losses in the retirement accounts, many retirees are being forced to go back to work.  Disappointment understandably runs deep among investors who together have $9.4 trillion in U.S. mutual funds.

Advice On Picking A Mutual Fund

Warren Buffet, the worldís greatest investor, said it best;  “I would not invest in mutual funds, but if I did, I would choose an index fund.  For most small investors who don’t have time to research individual companies, cheap index funds are the best way to invest in the stock market.”

First, an Index Mutual Fund is much cheaper to run than a typical actively managed mutual fund.  Because they track a target benchmark, rather than constantly buying and selling securities in an attempt to outperform the market.  Thus index funds generally have lower advisory fees, operating expenses, and trading costs than actively managed funds.  Once you eliminate those analysts’ salaries, an index fund can cut its costs tremendously.  And those savings can be passed along to investors in the form of higher returns.

Second, Index Mutual Funds perform better than most actively managed funds.  During the 1990s, in one of the best times in history for the market, the S&P 500 Index provided an annualized return of 17.3%, (including reinvestment of dividends and capital gains) compared with just 13.9% for the average equity mutual fund.  During the 1990s, the total shortfall between actively managed mutual funds and the market as measured by the S&P 500 Index was a whopping 3.4% per year.  And, that doesnít take into account the expense ratios, fees, and loads in those funds, which would bring the return down to 9.85%.  And that is one of the best times in history for the stock market!

In more recent history, only 4% of diversified US stock mutual funds have beaten the performance of the S&P 500 Index, over the past 10 years ending in 2007.

Of course, investing in an index mutual fund guarantees that you’ll never outperform the overall market.

Compare Mutual Funds To Deferred Annuities!

So, where should you be investing your money?  Would you have fared better with a deferred annuity over the past 28 years?

$100,000 Invested On Dec. 31, 1980, In A Hypothetical S&P Index Mutual Fund (That probably would have outperformed all actively managed mutual funds), Would Be Worth Approximately – $428,014 (That is after annual fees and expenses of 2.5% for the past 28 years)

$100,000 Invested On Dec. 31, 1980, In A Hypothetical Deferred Index Annuity, Would Be Worth Approximately – $553,263 (Based On An 80% Participation Rate) (Deferred Index Annuities do not charge management fees and they are 100% tax-efficient)

$100,000 Invested On Dec. 31, 1980, In A Typical Deferred Fixed Annuity, Would Be Worth Approximately – $583,162 (Based On An Average Of 6.5% Interest During The Past 28 Years) (Deferred Fixed Annuities do not charge management fees and they are 100% tax-efficient)

Who knows what the future will bring?  Will the stock market continue to deteriorate?  Probably.  Will interest rates start to climb?  Who knows?  One thing is for sure, most average middle-income families can’t afford to lose what little money they’ve saved.

So, with all the risks and fees involved, do you really belong in mutual funds or a deferred annuity?

Should you be selling deferred to your clients?

Help Your Clients See The Value Of Deferred Annuities!

Deferred annuities will provide more safety and guarantees for your clients! Selling and using deferred annuities will make sure all their money will be there when they need it the most!

Annuity Sales Excellence™ Tool Kit

Annuity Sales ExcellenceOur Annuity Sales Excellence Tool Kit (Deferred Annuity marketing and sales system) is about you helping retirees and boomers Maximize Their Spendable Income. While you Guarantee An Income They Can’t Outlive! (Selling Deferred And Immediate Annuities!)

Check out our Annuity Sales Excellence™ Tool Kit, because you will get 90 days of personal insurance agent success training and coaching… with back-office sales support! All from a team that has been training insurance agents and advisors for over 40 years to help retirees and boomers to buy deferred annuities. So agents will earn $250k or more per year selling deferred annuities and life insurance!

We will show you how to find your best-deferred annuity leads/prospects. So you will set great annuity sales appointments.

Then we will show you how to help your clients and prospects see and want to solve their money problems. We will also show you how you can help your clients and prospects to find the money so that they can take action right now! 

Then we will show you the best ways for you to present your solutions to your clients and prospects to close 9 out of 10 deferred and immediate annuity sales. So that you will earn $250K, or more this year selling deferred annuities and life insurance like the legends.

Includes… Our Annuity Lead Magnet™ Using Information Booklets & Reports,
Our Complete Annuity Seminar And Workshop System,
And Includes… Membership to Our Private Site at $29.95 per month after the first month,
Includes… 90 Days of Personal Insurance Agent Success Training, Coaching, and Back-Office Sales Support Worth $2,097!

When will you get the best system and training to sell deferred and immediate annuities?

When Will You Read Our Full-Length Book? So You Learn How To Really Help Middle-Income Families?

Living Debt Free And Truly Wealthy - Help Middle Income Families

Middle American Family’s Guide To Living Debt-Free And Truly Wealthy!

We urge you to take the time to read our 20 Chapter book… ‘Middle American Family’s Guide To Living Debt Free And Truly Wealthy“! Because we give you complete strategies, on how you can help middle-income families to find the money to spend, save, invest, insure, and plan wisely for a secure future! So that you can help them to “Live Debt Free and Truly Wealthy”! As a result, you will understand our philosophies, concepts, and techniques by the end of the book. And finally, you will know how you can make a real difference… By helping your family, friends, clients, and neighbors get rid of their debt. So they can save for retirement. So that they will have a secure financial future! And you will close more and larger insurance sales! Book Outline – Get A Digital Copy of Our 20 Chapter Book! Only $18.97, Immediate Download, ORDER Now!

Get The Annuity Marketing And Sales Systems, Tools, Training, and Support to Sell Deferred Annuities.
Help Middle-Income Families Buy Deferred And Immediate Annuities!

9 Financial Lessons For Creating Personal Wealth

5 Killer Life Insurance Prospecting And Sales Strategies

Insurance Agent Branding – A Classic Marketing Strategy!

Free Consult - Best Training For Helping 9 Out Of 10 Insurance Agents and Financial Advisors To Double And Triple Their Sales And Income In 60 Day Or Less!

Recommended By The Members Of The IARFC - Mutual Funds Vs Deferred Annuities!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.