Insurance Pro Shop

October 13, 2026 · By Jeremy Nason

Stop Looking for the Next Sales Trick. Start Doing What Works.

Why Consistency, Not Another Sales Technique, Is the Secret to Insurance Sales Success

Quick Answer: Many agents struggle not because they lack knowledge, but because they do not use what they know consistently. Build insurance sales success by making meaningful conversations, follow-up, good questions, activity tracking, and skill practice part of your regular routine.

Every insurance agent and financial advisor has experienced it.

You start the week motivated. You have big goals, a fresh attitude, and every intention of making this your best week ever.

Then reality hits.

A prospect cancels. Someone does not return your call. A client says they want to think about it. Before you know it, you are questioning your approach, your presentation, and even your ability to succeed.

So what do you do?

You start looking for something new. A better script. A new lead source. Another training program. Maybe a new tool that promises to make selling easier.

But ask yourself: What if the problem is not what you do not know? What if it is what you are not doing consistently?

The Problem Is Not Always Your Sales Skills

After more than 30 years of working with insurance agents and financial advisors, I have noticed something: many agents already know enough to succeed.

They know they need to prospect. They know questions matter. They know follow-up matters. They know how to present a solution.

Yet they struggle to get steady results.

Why? Because knowing what to do and doing it are two different things. Successful agents do not always have better leads, products, or personalities. They build the discipline to do the important work, even when they do not feel like it.

If you are searching for a new technique because of insurance prospects ghosting, pause before you change everything. First ask whether you are consistently doing the basics that help you understand, serve, and follow up with people.

Cartoon insurance agent tempted by a shiny shortcut while a steady path of small steps leads uphill

Stop Measuring Success by Today’s Sales

One of the biggest mistakes agents make is judging their success by what happened today.

No applications? Bad day. Two sales? Great day.

But sales do not always happen on your schedule. You might spend Monday calling, Tuesday following up, and Wednesday meeting prospects without writing an application. Then Thursday, three people decide to move forward.

Was Thursday the only successful day? Of course not. Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday helped create those results.

The activities you control today create the sales opportunities you may have tomorrow.

Instead of only counting sales, ask better questions:

  • How many meaningful conversations did I have?
  • How many people did I help recognize a financial problem or goal?
  • How many appointments did I schedule?
  • How many prospects did I follow up with?
  • Did I move my business forward today?

These activities help build a sustainable insurance and financial services practice. A weekly review can show you whether your work is steady, even when one day’s sales are not.

Your Next Sale May Be in Your Follow-Up List

Think about the prospects you spoke with over the last six months. How many said they were interested but not ready? How many asked you to call back? How many have not made a decision? How many have you contacted since?

Not everyone is ready to buy when you are ready to sell.

A person may need time. Their situation may change. They may need another conversation to understand their options. Following up with a real reason is not bothering someone. It gives them another chance to discuss a problem they may still have.

Before spending more money to find new leads, look at the opportunities already in your pipeline. Read The Follow-Up Problem That’s Costing You Sales and How Many Life Insurance Sales Are You Walking Past Every Week? for more ideas.

If insurance prospects ghosting is frustrating you, review what happened after the last conversation. Did you agree on a next step? Did you follow up when you said you would? Was your message relevant to what the person told you?

A couple reconnecting at their kitchen table in warm evening light, with children’s items in the background

The Best Salespeople Do Not Have All the Answers

Agents sometimes think they need to become better presenters to close more sales. Product knowledge, illustrations, and practice handling concerns all have value.

But the best conversations often happen when the agent talks less and listens more.

Your prospect may not wake up thinking about an indexed universal life policy, an annuity, or more life insurance. They may be thinking about family, retirement, debt, income, and what comes next.

Your job is not to convince them how wonderful a product is. Your job is to help them discover what matters, understand what may be missing, and consider what could happen if they do nothing.

Start with the client’s goals and cash flow. Ask where their money goes and whether debt, interest, or spending choices are working against what they want. Found Money Management applies this idea by helping clients look for money they may already be losing to financial inefficiencies before considering a new payment or product. Explore the Found Money Management system.

When a real insurance need appears, explore it. When it does not, do not force it. That is professional advice.

Follow a Conversation Framework, Not Just a Script

Scripts can help you learn how conversations work. They can show you how to open, ask questions, and move from one topic to the next. But do not memorize lines and ignore the person in front of you. Replace scripts with a natural framework that lets you listen and adapt.

Use these seven steps, in order:

  1. Get the facts. Understand the client’s situation.
  2. Get the goal. Ask what they want to accomplish.
  3. Get the why. Learn why the goal matters.
  4. Get the priority. Find out what matters most now.
  5. Say it back. Summarize what you heard and check that you understood.
  6. Ask permission. Invite them to hear ideas based on what they shared.
  7. Then present. Show a solution only after you understand the need.

For more on the process, read Insurance Fact Finding: Questions That Uncover Real Needs and Stop Answering Objections So Fast. You can also learn how to stop sounding scripted and why presenting a solution too soon can hurt the conversation.

If insurance prospects ghosting keeps happening after appointments, do not assume a better line is the answer. Ask whether you listened, understood the person’s priority, and agreed on a clear next step.

Give Yourself a 30-Day Challenge

For the next 30 days, stop searching for a magic sales technique. Commit to five simple activities:

  1. Start five meaningful prospect conversations every working day.
  2. Follow up with five existing prospects daily.
  3. Ask more questions than you answer during appointments.
  4. Track your activity instead of obsessing over daily sales.
  5. Spend at least 15 minutes improving one specific sales skill.

These are practice goals, not a promise that every conversation will become an appointment or every appointment will become a sale. Adjust your approach to each person, follow applicable contact rules, and respect anyone who asks you not to contact them.

You do not need to reinvent your business. You need to keep doing the fundamentals that create opportunities. For practical tools and training, visit the Insurance Pro Shop Resource Center.

“You don’t need a perfect plan. You need a full calendar. Activity is the only thing that turns a license into a living.”

Success Is Not About Having a Perfect Day

You are going to have difficult days. People will cancel. Prospects will say no. Some weeks will be better than others. That is part of this business.

The difference between agents who build lasting careers and those who keep struggling often comes down to what they do after a disappointing day.

Do they stop? Do they look for another shortcut? Or do they show up tomorrow and do the work again?

Your future success is not determined by yesterday. It is shaped by what you are willing to do consistently starting today. Read Why Insurance Agents Keep Starting Over Every 90 Days for more on staying with the work.

Stop chasing the magic answer. Start doing what works, and keep doing it long enough to learn from the results.

Ready to Build a More Consistent Sales Business?

At Insurance Pro Shop, we help insurance agents and financial advisors build the skills, confidence, and habits to grow a practice. Through weekly live coaching, sales training, prospecting strategies, and the Guided Discovery Method™, you can learn to create better conversations, uncover opportunities, and help prospects make informed decisions.

Insurance agent and coach reviewing an abstract progress chart together in a bright office

Join Insurance Pro Shop today for $39.95 per month. Your membership rate is locked in for life as long as you remain an active member. New membership pricing increases to $59.95 per month on January 1, 2027.

Explore Insurance Pro Shop Membership

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do insurance agents struggle to be consistent?

Many agents know the basics of prospecting, asking questions, following up, and presenting solutions, but do not do those things regularly. A simple routine and a focus on controllable activity can help them build more consistent habits.

What daily activities build insurance sales success?

Start meaningful prospect conversations, follow up with existing prospects, ask questions and listen during appointments, track your activity, and practice one sales skill. These actions build opportunities, though they do not guarantee a specific result.

How many follow-ups should an agent do each day?

The 30-day challenge in this article suggests following up with five existing prospects each working day. Treat that as a practice target, not a rule for every agent or prospect, and respect each person’s preferences and applicable contact requirements.

What is the Guided Discovery Method?

The Guided Discovery Method™ is an Insurance Pro Shop teaching framework for helping agents understand a client’s situation, goals, reasons, and priorities before presenting. It encourages agents to listen and adapt instead of relying on memorized lines.

How long does it take to see results from consistent activity?

There is no set timeline because results depend on your market, conversations, follow-up, and other factors. Consistent activity helps you build opportunities and learn which parts of your process need work, but it cannot promise when a sale will happen.


Want More Tips Like This? Become an IPS Member Today!

Jeremy, Training Members in the Weekly Virtual Training Class. Become A Member Today!
Jeremy, Training Members in the Weekly
Virtual Training Class. Become A Member Today!

If you found this blog post helpful, you’re going to love what’s waiting inside our Insurance Marketing and Sales Resource Center™.

For just $39.95/month, you get immediate access to:

✅ Step-by-step insurance marketing and prospecting strategies
✅ Proven sales training that helps you book better appointments and close larger cases
✅ Powerful fact-finding questions and sales scripts that make you the Trusted Advisor
✅ Live weekly coaching webinars (4 per month) + unlimited access to all past sessions
✅ Real-time case design and appointment prep support
✅ Access to our video training vault with 100+ hours of content
✅ A private community of agents and advisors growing together

We’ve helped thousands of agents and advisors go from struggling… to earning $100K, $200K, and more — without hype, gimmicks, or overpriced leads. Just real help from a team that’s been in the trenches.

You don’t have to do this alone. If you’re ready to make a real difference for your clients and build a business you’re proud of…

👉 Click Here to Join IPS Today – Risk-Free
$39.95/month • Cancel anytime • 30-Day Money Back Guarantee

Price increases to $59.95 by Nov 1.

#”The IPS membership is hands down the best money I’ve spent on my career. The tools, the support, and the guidance have transformed my business.” – Bryan G., MO


IPS Personalized Client Newsletters – Free Personalization

Do you want a stream of your ideal insurance clients and exclusive leads? Do you want to make it easy to set appointments and close life insurance sales? Then make sure your name and special insurance marketing message about how you help middle-income families is out there! So you are always in front of your ideal prospects.

Your client newsletter is critical to staying in touch with prospects, friends, family, and clients. It is also a key to more repeat sales and referrals (exclusive leads) from your current clients. So it is a huge key to you being a successful insurance agent!

Remember, ‘Out Of Sight, Out Of Mind’ is a deadly mistake for advisors. Why would your clients, friends, family, neighbors, or prospects call you when they need your help? Or when they are ready to buy. Since they never hear from you, don’t remember you, or know how you help middle-income families! And, then why would they refer people to you?


Are You Asking Your Clients Enough Insurance Sales Questions? Only $39.95
By Coach Jeremy Nason, RFC®

Asking Your Insurance Clients Enough Questions, To Set The Best Sales Appointments, To Close More Sales One of the recurring topics we write about each week… and talk about daily is asking your insurance prospects the right probing questions. And then ask your insurance prospects enough sales questions! That is because asking your prospects the right probing questions is one of, if not the biggest key to your success in selling insurance. Accordingly, agents have asked us for a complete list of probing sales questions to use with their insurance prospects! As a result, we have compiled a list of all of our favorite insurance sales questions. And we put them all into our limited edition e-book… Are You Asking Enough Insurance Sales Questions?  In this 24-page guide, you will find our goldmine of probing questions you should ask your prospects to set appointments and close insurance sales.  More Details! Immediate Download…  Order Now!

A huge key to finding and attracting exclusive leads, setting better appointments, closing sales, increasing your income, and successfully selling life insurance annuities and your services is and always will be getting the agent training to ask enough of the right sales questions!

“The key to a life insurance sale is an interview, and the key to an interview is a disturbing question.”


Learn How To Help People Find The Money? So You Can Set Appointments, Close Sales, And Make Big Money Selling Life Insurance Like Ben Feldman?

Middle American Family’s Guide To – Living Debt-Free And Truly Wealthy!
By Lew Nason, LUTCF, CTA, RFC® Retired, And Jeremy Nason RFC®

Middle American Family's Guide To Living Debt-Free And Truly Wealthy!

We urge you to take the time to read our 20-chapter book… Middle American Family Guide To Living Debt-Free And Truly Wealthy! Because we give you complete strategies… To help middle-income families find the money to spend, save, invest, insure, and plan wisely for a secure future! So you can help them “Live Debt-free and Truly Wealthy”! As a result, you will understand our philosophies and techniques by the end of the book. Finally, you will know how you can make a real difference… Helping your family, friends, clients, and neighbors to get rid of their debt. So they can save for retirement. So that they will have a secure financial future! Book Outline – Get A Digital Copy of Our 20 Chapter Book! Only $18.97, Immediate Download, ORDER Now!

Important Question… Are you in this insurance business to make sales? Or are you interested in helping families? Who do you think insurance prospects want to see? Do they want to meet with an insurance salesperson – or a Trusted Advisor who does their best to help them? When will you decide to make a real difference in people’s lives? The more personal insurance agent training, coaching, and sales support you get to learn how to successfully help families find the money… for a secure financial future. Then the more you will learn how to help yourself and your family! Nothing will change until you decide to take action to make it change!


Recommended By The Members Of The IARFC - The Life Insurance Sales Process for qualified prospects!... To Make The Big Money Selling life Insurance!